With some honesty ?Aceface wrote: Blimey, don't even know where to start with this.
This is what I wrote - and I notice you and one other poster who had a dig have both failed to use the quote :Aceface wrote: If we're going to pretend that wasn't a little jab at Antonio
Postby the pink palermo on Sun Sep 20, 2015 10:58 am
I don't think Jelavic worked nearly hard enough when he came on and as for Antonio, well, I'm not entirely sure what we've bought .In fairness having to come on yesterday wasn't the easiest situation .Hopefully he'll settle and we'll see what he can do
No, I would suggest you decided what it was without thinking about it .Aceface wrote:
- I think I know what it was,
Yes, a balanced comment based upon what I watched on Saturday .Aceface wrote: you know what it was,
That's quite a skill you have there .Aceface wrote: everyone knows what it was
Yes, you did .Aceface wrote: - then we'll just have to say I got it wrong
If I had wanted to say he was **** I would have done so .Aceface wrote: and that you aren't included in the small group of people who've commented since fulltime on Saturday that he looked a bit meh.
Really ? So you wouldn't think to form an opinion based upon a players physique, touch or pace appropriate - nothing to do with his contribution to the game by the way , just the factors that are unique to him .Aceface wrote: Or we can say that forming any kind of opinion at all of a PL debutant playing 20 minutes under the biggest onslaught the club has faced since around the time the Emirates opened is ludicrous,
What I saw and why I commented "I'm not entirely sure what we've bought" was related to his physique more than anything : He looked huge to me , looked to have some pace when he got a head of steam up albeit didn't look that quick off the mark .Those are things a poster can comment on quite legitimately regardless of the game situation .
Can you honestly say you've never watched a player for a few minutes and said " he looks like he has a good touch" ? If so, why would someone not be allowed to comment on a player and say "he looks like he has a poor first touch" .